What is TONE?
Tone is that subjective, magical, mystical, ear pleasing
quality of music that defies definition. We know it when
we hear it but we can’t describe it. Usually, it goes
something like this: I want that tone that Stevie Ray,
or Eddie Van Halen, etc., etc. has on song XYZ. Will
your amp make me sound like…..? The short answer is: No.
The long answer is: Maybe. There is no right or wrong
answer to this question. The tone you get from a system
starts with your hands, goes through your guitar,
through the amplifier, through the air, and back to your
ears. The tone you get from a system is the sum of the
parts. If it pleases your ears it’s good tone. If it
really pleases your ears it’s fabulous tone.
I play ABC genre/style of music. Will your amp Model X allow
me to cover that style? The short answer is: Probably. The
long answer is: The question is too broad with too many
variables. Our combo amps, like the Lindy Fralin and Blue
Bel Aire, will cover most styles of music from Jazz to Blues
to Rock and Roll. We believe that our head amps like the
Rick Derringer or Earthquake models will cover almost any
style or genre of music. Again, the tone you get from a
system is the sum of the parts. How do you play? Do you pick
the strings hard? Are your pickups hot? Will they drive the
amp to early distortion? You have to answer these questions
yourself and decide what will suit your style.
Are your amps wired point-to-point or do you use PC boards?
Building guitar amps by hand in the good ol’ USA is
expensive and we have a lot of very good competition.
Our mission has always been to build the best amps
possible and make them affordable. So, we use
point-to-point wiring, hand made eyelet boards, turret
boards, PC boards, and any other method we can think of
the achieve our goal. Many of our peers would say we’re
sacrilegious but we’ve built hundreds of amps and
repaired thousands of guitar amps since 1969. Based on
our experience, there is no tone magic in point-to-point
wiring, eyelet boards, or any of the other bunk that the
“experts” get so worked up about.
There is, however, real magic in the choice of parts and
component placement/layout. Are we saying that a PC
board amp can sound as good as an amp wired
point-to-point? To this question we can emphatically
say: Yes! Moreover, we get much better consistency from
PC boards over our short production runs than we do from
amps wired point-to-point. That being said, there is a
down side to PC boards; they are not easy to modify or
tweak. The design is etched in copper so to speak. Other
than that, there is no down side if it’s well designed.
And, we have seen many poorly designed PC boards with
power sources in parallel with signal paths and high
density component layouts that induce noise and
capacitance topped off with cheap components that sucks
the tone out of a well conceived design. Usually, these
are high production amps with very familiar names but
not always. We’ve seen the same problems in “boutique”
amps. At VVT we build our prototypes with a combination
of point-to-point wiring and hand made eyelet boards on
FR4/G10 phenolic. After we are satisfied with our choice
of components and overall layout we tweak and voice the
amp to perfection. Then, we make a short run of 5-10
amps and test them for consistency. If all goes well, we
design a PC board with attributes and layout as close to
the hand made eyelet board as possible. We mount our
choice of components by hand, solder them by hand, and
build the amps by hand. If having a PC board in your amp
bothers you please let us know. We will build any amp
your heart desires point-to-point but it will cost more
than our amps made with a PC board.
What circuit is your amp based on?
This is a very hard question for us to answer. After
repairing and playing so many amps and looking at the
schematics over many years, they all begin to look alike. We
have not seen any new designs in tube guitar amplifiers
since the early-sixties. Even then, the designers borrowed
pieces and parts from others. If a contemporary amp builder
has a design that was new and different then he would have a
patent. We’ve researched patents and there aren’t any of
significance. We have not seen any contemporary tube type
guitar amps that were truly engineered from the ground up.
However, there are certain tone qualities of some amps that
really stand out. We use this to our advantage and take the
best pieces of those amps and build them into our amps. We
don’t reverse engineer any particular amp and try to mimic
that tone. We don’t have the holy grail of vintage amps that
we used to measure component drift and other such nonsense.
There are many other amp builders that make clones and they
do it very well. We just start with an idea for the tone we
want and go from there. Let’s say we really like the tone of
old plexi amps but don’t like how they respond to pick
attack at lower volumes or how they respond to different
pickups, etc., etc. We start thinking about how we can make
it better and more versatile. To do this we need
transformers with a specific voltage or such and such
impedance, and components with certain tonal attributes. So,
we order the parts and build a prototype. Sometimes, things
work out very well. Other times, as in the case of our
Overdrive amps, we tweak for years before we offer the amp
for sale. If you want a clone of a particular amp please let
us know; we will build it for you. But, clones are not part
of our standard amp line. For example, the Lindy Fralin
Model has many of the fine tone qualities of some vintage BF
and Tweed amps but it is not based on any particular amp
design.
Want More Headroom?
How can I get more headroom out of my amp?
We get this question all the time and there are several
answers depending on your definition of “clean” or
“headroom”. Headroom, in this case, is the capacity of
your amplifier to reproduce audio signals from your
pickups before distortion. Tube type guitar amplifiers
are not High Fidelity equipment; they all have a point
where they will start to distort (breakup). If you want
clean tone, i.e. limited distortion, from your amplifier
at higher volume levels there are several things to
consider:
1. Pickups. If the output of your guitar pickup is hot, it
will drive the amp harder at the front end and may cause the
preamp to distort at lower volume. Try turning down the
volume on your guitar. We all know that a typical humbucker
pickup has more output signal than a typical single coil
pickup. You may or may not be surprised at the myriad of
tones and the headroom available by controlling the volume
knob on your guitar.
2. Preamp Tubes. According to the RCA Tube manual, a 12AX7
high mu dual triode has an amplification factor of 100.
However, this factor can vary greatly from manufacturer to
manufacturer. We know from testing several NOS RCA 12AX7s
that some exhibit higher gain than others in a given
circuit. Additionally, gain, or amplification, can vary
greatly within the two triodes of the tube. The same is true
for newly manufactured tubes from Europe, Russia, and China.
So, try several different preamp tubes in your amp to
improve headroom. You can also try a tube like the 12AY7
with an amplification factor of 70.
3. Phase Inverter Tube. The PI is usually overlooked when it
comes to headroom. Try different tubes here as well. If your
amp has a 12AX7 in the PI try replacing it with a 12AY7 or
12AT7/ECC81.
4. Output Tubes. There is a lot of misinformation related to
this topic but….matched output tubes are critical to clean
headroom. Unmatched tubes will definitely affect crossover
distortion and apparent headroom. The downside is that the
tubes will age at different rates and will become unmatched
in a fairly short time. Don’t expend too much effort here
but matched tubes are always a good starting point. Also, as
with preamp tubes, output tubes from different manufacturers
will have more inherent headroom (and different tone
qualities) than others. It’s always a trade-off.
5. Speakers. Speakers play a crucial role in the amount of
headroom the amp exhibits, so before you say my amp needs
more headroom it could be your speakers. As speakers begin
to break up, they also begin to compress, causing a change
in the frequency response. This becomes very noticeable in
the lower notes as they lose focus and start to produce a
gritty type of grind. If this is the case you may need to
increase the power handling capability of your speakers. A
good place to start is by doubling the speaker’s power
rating from that of your amps power section. If your amp is
rated at 50 watts, your speaker or speakers should be rated
around 100 watts. Keep in mind this is a starting point. If
you like a little speaker breakup try a 75 or 80 watt
configuration. If you want no breakup, go to a 150 watt
setup. There are no set rules here. Stevie Ray Vaughan liked
a 200 watt EVL in his Vibroverbs (50 watt amp), virtually no
speaker breakup. Speaker choice is a very personal issue and
has a great impact on tone and headroom. Both the Fralin and
Blue Bel-Aire’s speakers have been designed for small
(100-150 seat), halls or restaurant type gigs and still stay
relatively clean. This makes them pedal friendly as well as
a great platform for many styles of music.
Should I get a 100 watt amp or a 50 watt?
Despite what you have read or what you might think, 100
watt tube amps will not produce twice the volume of a 50
watt tube amp. The difference in volume is about 3db
which is barely audible. Where you will hear the
difference is in the TONE of the amp. 100 watt amps will
seem louder due to the increased bandwidth propagated by
the extra output tubes, this decreases the load on the
tubes themselves so you don’t get the anomalies
associated with a tube about to clip. This gives the amp
more headroom, increased low end, better touch
sensitivity, and a clearer cleaner top end, in effect
making the amp seem louder since you are hearing a
clearer richer sound produced by 4 tubes instead of 2.
100 watt amps are not that much more expensive than a 50
watt amp. Slightly larger transformers and 2 more output
tubes (as well as the capability of turning off 2 of the
tubes essentially converting the amp back to 50 watts)
gives you an amp that will go from a small club amp to
an outdoor arena style amp.
So remember if someone says 100 watts don’t think volume
think TONE!! All of our 100 watt amps come with a volume
control no extra charge. ?
What is Cathode bias (aka) Auto Bias versus fixed bias?
Cathode bias is an early method of biasing tubes where a
resistor is placed in the cathode. Current draw through
this resistor makes the grid potential negative with
respect to the cathode. And, changes in tube conduction
are automatically compensated by changes in bias so it’s
also referred to Auto Bias. In Fixed Bias a negative
voltage is applied directly to the grids of the output
tubes. It should be noted that preamp tube are almost
always cathode biased whereas output tubes may be either
or both. Without getting into the technical issues of
the difference between a fixed bias/cathode bias we will
talk about the tonal qualities and how they differ in
the real world.
The Pros and Cons.
Fixed Biased:
Fixed biased amps are more efficient, it is a brighter,
tighter, punchier tone and needs to be pushed louder to find
a warm sweet spot. Fixed bias also increases the headroom of
the output section keeping the amp cleaner as it gets
louder, yet the transition into grind is bit edgier. This
design also requires you to bias the amp when replacing
output tubes.
On the whole, most amps are fixed bias, your Blackface
Fenders, Marshalls, and many of the newer amps such as
Boogies etc.
Cathode biased:
Cathode biased amps have a slightly browner tone giving them
a real warm appeal.
They also seem to have a rounder more full tone at lower
volumes, and transition into grind smoother than a fixed
biased amp. They also begin to compress sooner and have a
more round, less focused low end, as well as a sweeter
compressed, less edgy top end. They also have slightly less
headroom.
Cathode biased amps don’t need to be re-biased when
installing a fresh set of output tubes (but the set still
needs to be matched). It is also a good idea to try and
replace the output tubes with the same current draw as the
originals. Most manufactures of tubes use a numbering system
or color code to identify the tube’s draw. This keeps the
tubes at the proper operating point.
Cathode biased amps include, Vox AC 30’s, older Fender Tweed
amps such as the Pro, Tweed Deluxe etc.
The description above explains the differences in tone in
the same amp with a fixed bias/ cathode biased conversion.
This is not to say a cathode biased Vox AC 30 won’t have as
much headroom if not more than a fender tweed Deluxe, the
intention is to describe the tonal differences you will
notice in either design.
We designed the Fralin Model around the appeal of the
cathode biased design yet give the amp more clean headroom
than the earlier Tweed Fenders.
Are your amps Class A?
This question always opens a can of worms but the answer
is: No. All of our amps operate in Class AB except our
single ended amps which operate in Class A. The amp
class debate is, and will continue to be, like herding
cats. There is some good information and much
disinformation on this subject available on the web. You
decide which one is best for you based on a listening
test. It should be known, however, that just because an
amp is cathode biased doesn’t mean that it’s operating
in Class A. That’s just a marketing scam.
|